Business Details
25 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining in York's Heart
Established in 2001, Toto's is a family-run Italian restaurant nestled in the heart of York, offering an authentic culinary experience rooted in tradition. Founded by Antony and Paola, our establishment embodies a lifelong passion for Italian cuisine, inspired by the legacy of renowned comedian Tot. We pride ourselves on using fresh, high-quality ingredients to craft dishes that reflect Italy's rich gastronomic heritage, served in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Located just five minutes from York city centre, adjacent to the historic York Barbican, we provide a unique dining destination that combines charm with exceptional service. Our commitment to excellence has been recognised through TripAdvisor's Certificate of Excellence, reflecting our dedication to customer satisfaction.Every day, our skilled chefs meticulously prepare a diverse menu featuring classic starters, wood-fired pizzas, handmade pasta, and seasonal specials, catering to both intimate gatherings and larger celebrations. With a carefully curated wine list and proximity to York's cultural attractions, Toto's offers the perfect setting for pre- or post-theatre dining. We maintain rigorous standards of hygiene and ingredient traceability, ensuring every meal meets our exacting quality benchmarks. Our team's collective experience spans decades, blending traditional techniques with contemporary presentation to deliver consistent excellence. Whether you're a local resident or visiting York, we strive to create memorable dining experiences that celebrate the essence of Italian hospitality.
Services
Starters
Wood-fired Pizza
Handmade Pasta
Seasonal Specials
Wine List
Pre-theatre Dining
Private Celebrations
Lunch Menu
Vegetarian Options
Gluten-free Dishes
Details
- Year established: 2001
Highlights and features
- We've specialised in authentic Italian cuisine since 2001 with family heritage in traditional recipes
- TripAdvisor-accredited establishment maintaining consistent quality standards for over two decades
- Daily-prepared dishes using fresh, traceable ingredients sourced through trusted suppliers
- Strategically located next to York Barbican for convenient pre/post-theatre dining
- Skilled chefs combine classical techniques with modern presentation for consistent excellence
Associations and certifications
- TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence
Services
Starters
Our starter menu features traditional Italian appetisers prepared with premium ingredients. From garlic bread topped with house-made tomato basil sauce to fresh mozzarella caprese with aromatic oregano, each dish showcases authentic flavours. We offer both individual portions and sharing platters for groups, including specialty items like deep-fried calamari with tartare sauce and antipasto misto with cured meats and bruschetta.
Wood-fired Pizza
Hand-stretched pizza bases are baked in our traditional wood-fired oven to achieve perfect crispiness. Choose from classic Margherita with San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella or specialty options like Salmone E Panna with smoked salmon and cream. All pizzas use imported Italian ingredients and follow time-honoured preparation methods for authentic results.
Handmade Pasta
Daily-prepared fresh pasta forms the basis of our traditional Italian dishes. From tagliatelle with homemade bolognese to ricotta-stuffed cannelloni, each portion is made to order. Our chefs use regional recipes passed through generations, ensuring authentic taste profiles in every bite of our hand-cut tagliatelle and filled pasta varieties.
Seasonal Specials
Our experienced chefs create daily-changing specials based on the freshest available ingredients. Featuring premium cuts of meat and sustainably sourced seafood, these dishes reflect current seasonal produce. The specials menu changes regularly to showcase regional Italian recipes and contemporary interpretations of classic dishes.
Wine List
We offer an extensive selection of Italian wines carefully chosen to complement our menu. Our list includes renowned varietals from Tuscany, Piedmont, and Veneto regions, featuring crisp whites, robust reds, and sparkling options. Wines are available by the glass or bottle, with expert pairing suggestions available from our knowledgeable staff.
People
Anthony Pugh
Owner
Co-founder Anthony Pugh established Toto's in 2001 to share authentic Italian cuisine with York. With family roots in Italian gastronomy, he oversees menu development and maintains quality standards across all dishes.
Questions
What makes Totos' Italian cuisine authentic?
Our recipes originate from traditional Italian regions, using imported ingredients and preparation methods passed through generations of Italian chefs.
Are vegetarian options available on the menu?
Yes, we offer multiple vegetarian dishes including our popular Tagliatelle Vegetariana with seasonal vegetables and garlic tomato sauce.
Can I book for large groups or special occasions?
We accommodate parties of all sizes with advance reservations, offering dedicated tables and tailored service for celebrations.
Is Totos near York's main attractions?
We're located directly next to York Barbican, just five minutes' walk from the city's major cultural venues and historic sites.
Do you offer gluten-free alternatives?
Yes, we provide gluten-free pasta options and can adapt many dishes to meet dietary requirements with advance notice.
Reviews (7)
Rose Miller
Jan 10, 2022
Report
Big mistake. Just go somewhere else! Food is disgusting and overpriced. I felt sick after the undercooked pizza that taste like Elios frozen pizza. delivered the wrong order.
Stewart Murphy
Jan 09, 2022
Report
I just called and the call take to me she had to put me in the system. This is very shocking because we order here all the time. It's actually my daughters favorite cheese steak place. But anyway, after giving my information. The call taker asked someone do they deliver to my address. The call taker then informs me that I am out of delivery range. And would have to pickup the food. This ridiculous because I am 4 minutes away and ALWAYS get delivery. I will be taking my business elsewhere for now on.
Sandra Lee
Jan 08, 2022
Report
This past Saturday l ordered a X-Large pizza, Veggie and half Sausage with the veggies. I was first shocked that the pizza cost $35 and when the pizza was delivered it was cold, and it appeared the toppings was put on an already cooked plain pizza. Very disappointed with the cost and the quality of the pizza.
Sam Alpert
Dec 16, 2021
Report
Recently started ordering here, it's been grand every single time. Such great food!! This was my old review, but the quality has just gone down hill so fast. I live a couple blocks away yet my pizza is cold? There's almost no cheese on my pizza. Just not the same quality it used to be:(
Candido Paredes
Oct 12, 2021
Report
Great Pizza place, I recommend, I always order a eggplant sandwich and chicken parmesan, I highly recommend
Timothy Meitzler
Aug 26, 2021
Report
I've had pizza everywhere and I will and I believe that this guy can put anything on a pizza you folded in here and often falls off then falls off I was working there for 2 weeks in the neighborhood in one and every day we ate To this day sometimes I say man I gotta drive up there and get some pizza and hes about 10 miles from me.
Roberta Moore
Jun 30, 2021
Report
My review is for the stromboli, pizza and calzones which we order fairly regularly. After trying most of the pizza places in Germantown/Mt. Airy, Toto's, is hands down, the best. The owner gets to know you and what you order pretty quickly - and isn't that a big factor? Our favorite is the Green Street pizza (pictured) which is LOADED with veggies. We just learned that they also make a vegan pizza but just marinara sauce and vegan cheese didn't wow me (we still might try it). Stromboli's are huge and the Calzone was also good but being lactose intolerant, we don't get it often because of the ricotta
