Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Iconic Seafood Restaurant in Whitby Harbour
Established in 1939, Magpie Cafe has grown into one of North Yorkshire's most renowned dining destinations, celebrated for its exceptional seafood and historic ambiance. Our family-owned business has been serving fresh, responsibly sourced fish since the post-war era, with generations of expertise informing every dish we prepare. Our culinary team, led by chefs with decades of local experience, crafts traditional British favourites using time-honoured recipes while maintaining rigorous quality standards. Located in Whitby's iconic black-and-white building overlooking the harbour, we combine centuries-old maritime history with modern hospitality.We're proud to have maintained our position as a regional leader in seafood cuisine through consistent quality and service excellence. Our commitment to sustainability ensures future generations can enjoy North Sea delicacies. Recognised by national guides including The Good Food Guide, we offer both dine-in and takeaway options. Our online shop extends our quality seafood offerings to customers nationwide. Through corporate transparency and decades of community engagement, we remain a trusted local institution. This dedication earned us a Lilliput Lane commemorative ornament, cementing our status as a Yorkshire landmark.
Services
Fish Restaurant
Takeaway Service
Group Bookings
Online Seafood Sales
Cookware Shop
Details
- Year established: 1939
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1954 with generations of culinary expertise
- Sustainably sourced North Sea fish prepared by award-winning chefs
- Historic Whitby landmark with uninterrupted quality since 1939
- Featured in The Good Food Guide and Restaurant Guru listings
- Offering both fine dining and convenient takeaway options
What people say
Exceptional food
Generous portions
Fresh fish
Attentive service
Unique location
Services
Fish Restaurant
Our flagship dining experience serves freshly caught North Sea fish prepared using traditional recipes. Daily specials feature local catches while classic dishes maintain exacting standards. The historic setting combines Whitby's maritime heritage with contemporary service excellence, offering panoramic harbour views.
Takeaway Service
Premium takeaway service offers signature dishes for enjoying off-site. Customers can collect freshly prepared seafood meals using our streamlined ordering system. Options include traditional fish and chips through to speciality chowders, maintaining the same quality standards as restaurant service.
Group Bookings
Dedicated event space accommodates larger parties during specified hours. We provide tailored menus and service for groups while maintaining our signature quality. Advance reservations ensure optimal arrangements for special occasions.
Online Seafood Sales
Curated selection of premium seafood available for nationwide delivery. Products use identical quality standards as restaurant ingredients. The Whitby Catch brand extends our reputation for fresh North Sea fish to home cooks and professional kitchens.
Cookware Shop
Specialist cookware store offering professional-grade culinary equipment. Located in the historic Whitby premises, the shop provides tools for seafood preparation and general cooking. Products reflect the same quality focus as our restaurant offering.
People
Ian Robson
Chef Proprietor
Has led The Magpie's kitchen since 1980, bringing over 50 years' experience to maintain our seafood excellence. His culinary expertise combines traditional methods with modern innovation while preserving quality standards.
Alison McKenzie Slater
Proprietor
Fourth-generation owner with family ties to the business since 1954. Oversees operations while ensuring continuity of the traditions established by her grandparents and parents through decades of Whitby hospitality.
Paul Gildroy
Head Chef
Began his career at The Magpie aged 12 and now leads culinary innovation while preserving historic recipes. His 30+ years' experience ensures consistent quality in every seafood preparation.
Duncan Robson
Restaurant Manager
Brings business expertise to our operations alongside hands-on management. Balances economic principles with hospitality traditions, expanding our offerings through initiatives like The Magpie's Kitchen cookware shop.
Louise Middlemas
Sous Chef
Transitioned from sports science to professional kitchens, now serving as Head Chef's key collaborator. Ensures day-to-day culinary execution maintains The Magpie's exacting standards across all food preparations.
Questions
What are your opening hours?
We serve Monday to Sunday from 11:30 to 21:00, with last orders taken at 21:00. Our hours remain consistent throughout the year.
Do you offer takeaway fish and chips?
Yes, our takeaway service provides the same quality seafood as our restaurant. David Barsby manages daily operations, offering convenient collection from our Whitby premises.
Can I buy your seafood online?
Our Whitby Catch brand delivers premium North Sea fish nationwide. Orders receive the same quality selection as our restaurant ingredients, available through our dedicated website.
Are pets allowed inside?
While we appreciate all visitors, only registered assistance animals can enter our restaurant under current policies. This ensures food hygiene and comfort for all customers.
How do group bookings work?
We accommodate groups during specified hours. Contact our reservations team through our website or phone to arrange preferred dates and discuss tailored menu options.
What makes your fish special?
All seafood is responsibly sourced from North Sea catches. Generations of experience ensure precise preparation techniques while maintaining traditional recipes from our 1939 heritage.
Reviews (5)
Nicola Smith
Feb 04, 2022
Report
Visited today for a special birthday. 95! The 2 ladies serving couldn’t do enough for us. Made the day so special. Food was stunning as always
Fizzleton
Jan 24, 2022
Report
First visit. Fantastic service and the food was incredible. The seafood pot throughly recommended. Can't wait to return. Thanks Magpie!
Anne Wheeler
Jan 21, 2022
Report
It was my birthday and we had the most delicious meal the waitress was really friendly and efficient being locals it’s so great to have such a good place to eat whether it’s a special occasion or just a treat love it never ever been disappointed
Anna Gill
Jan 21, 2022
Report
Super clean, friendly staff, knowledgeable staff! Fish dishes looked amazing. But we enjoyed the ham, egg, pineapple and chips. The vegetarian option of goats cheese salad.
Ham was super tasty, chips amazing and the goats cheese salad, so tasty!
Enjoyed a vintage Sherry trifle, sadly no photos of the apple crumble as hubby dived in before I could take a picture. Highly recommend this restaurant.
Ham was super tasty, chips amazing and the goats cheese salad, so tasty!
Enjoyed a vintage Sherry trifle, sadly no photos of the apple crumble as hubby dived in before I could take a picture. Highly recommend this restaurant.
Andy Hodson
Jan 04, 2022
Report
People over time have told me how good this fish and chip restaurant is. As far as I’m concerned we paid over £36 for a decent cup of tea! The chips were undercooked and the fish dreadful. It’s just an opinion but if you enjoy fish and chips here you have never tried them anywhere else. I have never not been able to finish my fried fish, I left half of it. 2/10 and I’m being generous because the cup of tea was nice.